Transcript 0:04 August 8th, 2023 looked like any other summer day in Lahaina, except it really wasn't. Hurricane Dora churned south of the Hawaiian Islands, driving unprecedented winds across Maui. 0:15 Multiple fires were already burning across the island, stretching emergency resources. The tourists still browsed Front Street shops. The locals went about their routines. The weather service had issued its warnings. 0:27 The firefighters stood ready but were already responding to other blazes. The emergency managers monitored deteriorating conditions, and the power lines swayed violently in the wind. 0:37 Everything was normal until it wasn't. Until it really wasn't. Hi, everyone. Welcome to the CrisisLab Podcast. 0:46 I'm going to share today an article that we published on LinkedIn called The Most Expensive Report Ever Written Again. 0:53 So in the devastating aftermath of the Lahaina fire, investigators poured through nearly two terabytes of data, conducting hundreds of interviews and produced thousands of pages of analysis. 1:02 A few months later, Maui Emergency Management Agency released its own after-action report, adding another volume to the library of disaster postmortems. 1:10 So stop me if you've read these reports before, but here's what makes these reports different. 1:16 When you read them together, they expose a truth the emergency management community has been reluctant to confront, how deeply governance choices determine our ability to succeed or fail. So consider this. 1:27 Hawaii had to abolish its state fire marshal position in 1979, replacing it with a state fire council. Now, that wasn't just an organizational decision. 1:36 It was a governance choice that would shape coordination capabilities and professional standards across the state for decades. 1:42 When multiple fires erupted across Maui on August 8th, the emergency management team found themselves understaffed, operating with, quote, limited pre-event incident action planning, unquote. 1:54 And this wasn't a failure of individual emergency managers. It was the predictable outcomes of governance choices that treated emergency management positions as optional rather than essential. So are you seeing this yet? 2:07 We keep talking about professionalizing emergency management as if it's simply a matter of better training or stricter certification, but that's actually backwards. Look at any established profession. 2:18 Take a certified public accountant. Businesses don't hire CPAs because they're a certification available. 2:25 They hire CPAs because governance systems from corporate law to SEC requirements recognize financial management as a central function of business operations. The professional standards followed. They didn't lead. 2:38 The same patterns hold true for established professions. Professional standards don't create institutional recognition. They follow it. 2:46 Professional requirements exist because governance systems first recognize these functions as essential. 2:52 Yet here we are debating emergency management certifications while governance systems still treat emergency management as a peripheral duty rather than central to government operations. 3:01 The Lahaina and MIMA reports document the cost of this fundamental disconnect. Now the parallel becomes even starker when we consider the consequences of failure. 3:11 When businesses fail at financial management, they risk bankruptcy. When a government fails at emergency management, people die. Communities are destroyed, billions in properties lost, and trust in government erodes. 3:23 The Lahaina fire's toll was 102 lives lost, over 2,000 structures destroyed, and billions in damages. 3:29 The MIMA agency report documents how governance choices that treated emergency management as a peripheral activity rather than a central activity contributed directly to these losses. 3:38 And yet, while business failures trigger immediate governance reforms and stricter professional standards, catastrophic failures in emergency management somehow lead to more reports but little fundamental change in how governments view the function itself. 3:52 These reports document how governance decisions flow directly into emergency management capabilities. So when emergency management positions aren't required to have specific qualifications, that's a governance choice. 4:03 When prevention programs go unfunded while response budgets swell, that is also a governance choice. And when emergency managers aren't included in key policy discussions, that is a governance choice. 4:14 And when professional standards are treated as optional, that's also a governance choice. So each of these choices shapes what emergency managers can achieve long before any disaster strikes. 4:25 So how many communities need to pay the price before we recognize emergency management as essential to governance as financial management is to business? 4:34 How many more lives lost before we understand that treating emergency management as a peripheral activity rather than a central one to government operations isn't just an organizational choice, it's a moral failure? 4:46 The next disaster is already being shaped by governance decisions being made today. And the next report is already being written. 4:53 The only question is whether we'll finally confront the connection between how we govern and how we manage emergencies. 4:59 Because until we do, we keep reading the same expensive reports paid for with lives lost, communities destroyed, and trust eroded, wondering why nothing changes. Thanks for listening to the CrisisLab podcast. 5:13 If you've got any comments or questions on this topic or anything else, please reach out to me on LinkedIn. I'm more than happy to hear from you and hear what you're thinking.